Federal Court orders $6.75m penalties over unlawful car loans

18 November 2026
Share this article
Federal Court orders $6.75m penalties over unlawful car loans

The Federal Court has ordered two car dealerships and a director to pay a combined $6.75 million in penalties over unlicensed lending and unlawful interest.

Keo Automotive was ordered to pay $3.5 million, while Diamond Wheels, which traded as Lansvale Motor Group, was ordered to pay $2.5 million.

Ken Keomanivong, director of Keo Automotive and former director of Diamond Wheels, was ordered to pay a further $750,000 for his involvement in the misconduct.

The court also restrained Keomanivong from involvement in credit activities for five years.

 
 

What happened?

The penalties follow proceedings commenced by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) in September 2024 over hundreds of unlicensed car loans, which required consumers to pay significantly more interest than was permitted under credit legislation.

In June 2026, the court found Diamond Wheels and Keo Automotive had engaged in unlicensed credit activities and charged unlawful interest.

It also found Keomanivong was involved in the contraventions and played a central role in establishing and operating the lending businesses. For at least part of the relevant period, he knew his conduct was unlawful.

All three defendants admitted the contraventions following 19 months of litigation. However, while Keomanivong agreed to the penalty imposed, Diamond Wheels and Keo Automotive challenged the penalties sought by ASIC.

md discover

Judge questions ASIC's penalty demands

The penalties were lower than those originally sought by ASIC, which had asked the Court to order Diamond Wheels to pay $6.5 million and Keo Automotive $9 million.

During the November hearing, Justice Lee questioned the disparity between the penalties ASIC was seeking from the companies and the $750,000 penalty it had agreed to seek from Keomanivong.

"I am having a little trouble reconciling the position of ASIC to agree on a penalty of $750,000 for Mr [Ken] Keomanivong and yet pushing… the penalty you seek in respect of the corporate respondents," he said, adding; “It can’t be all out of whack. There has got to be some rational relationship between the penalty I impose on one contravener and the penalty I impose on others.”

He also challenged ASIC's approach to calculating the benefit derived from the lending, which included the full value of the loan contracts.

"Properly analysed, the benefit … was the profit margin on each sale which would not have occurred save for this arrangement together with the interest benefit … That's what we've got to look at, isn't it? It's the amount that they trouser," he said.

“I just don’t understand how revenue can be a benefit.”

ASIC had also sought a permanent restraint preventing Keomanivong from engaging in regulated consumer credit activity. However, Justice Lee questioned whether such an order was necessary, asking whether it suggested an inability to impose a penalty that would provide effective deterrence.

“Doesn’t a permanent restraint, however, seem to suggest that there’s an inability to fix a penalty at an appropriate standard which will provide effective specific deterrence? Or general deterrence?”

Keomanivong was ultimately restrained from engaging in regulated consumer credit activity for five years.

The current director of Diamond Wheels, Mark Keomanivong, said he accepted the Court’s decision for the historical conduct.

"We regret that the lending occurred, and took action when it was discovered," he added.

Court warns against unlawful consumer lending

ASIC commissioner Alan Kirkland said consumers taking out car loans were entitled to the protections provided by Australia’s consumer credit laws.

“This misconduct occurred over many years and involved hundreds of loans being provided without the licence required by law,” Kirkland said.

“These penalties demonstrate the serious consequences of providing credit unlawfully and denying consumers important protections.”

In delivering his reasons, Justice Lee said the penalties were intended to “communicate to vehicle dealers and others who facilitate consumer finance that the regulatory requirements are not optional”.

The case against Diamond Wheels and Keo Automotive forms part of a commitment made by ASIC to stamp out predatory lending.

A review by ASIC in March 2025 found that some lenders had entered into unsuitable contracts or had failed to identify an appropriate target market for their products and distribution strategies.

Another case that ASIC has been pursuing is against Money3 Loans, which the Federal Court has ordered to pay $1.55 million in penalties.

The court found that the specialist lender had breached responsible lending obligations on five loans written between May 2019 and February 2021.

[Related: Fraud headlines ‘paint industry with one brush’, brokers warn]

Broker DailyWant to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Broker Daily a preferred news source on Google.
Tags: